• About

anactofmind

~ If there is anything in the world that can really be called a man's property, it is surely that which is the result of his mental activity. – Arthur Schopenhauer

anactofmind

Category Archives: Eucharist

The Four Competing Eucharistic Doctrines of the Roman Church resulting from the Council of Trent

12 Saturday Jan 2013

Posted by Paul Bassett in Eucharist, Reformation, Roman Catholicism, Trent, Unity

≈ 1 Comment

In my last post I endeavored to explore the diversity of doctrine in the Roman Church with regard to the pinnacle of its faith – the Eucharist – at the time of the Council of Trent.  And in that post I mentioned Fr. Daly’s examination[i] of four competing doctrines resulting from the work of theologians in the years after Trent.  A gentleman named Scot asked me to enumerate them and so I shall.

Fr. Daly begins with the current state of the Eucharistic celebration and works back to Trent.  It seems that his analysis causes him to note fundamental problems in the Roman Catholic doctrine of the Eucharist today, which finds its roots in Trent:

It should be noted that this idea of sacramental representation, although now quite characteristic of contemporary Catholic theology, is actually one of the weak points of that theology.  For this theory – that the historical saving acts of Christ are “metahistorically” made present to us – is not significantly supported by the biblical witness, nor by the Jewish background, nor by broad patristic evidence.  Still more, it is also the kind of theory that creates further problems, since there is little agreement among scholars on how to explain what is being asserted.[ii]

So what followed from Trent’s “true and proper sacrifice” language was really not at all clear or unified.  In fact, Daly writes,

…one must remember that Trent never explained what it meant by “sacrifice”.  That was left to the theologians to argue about…Inevitably, the Catholic theology of the Eucharist after Trent became extremely complicated. [iii]

Fr. Daly then relies on the work of Marius Lepin[iv], a Sulpician and founder of the Servants of Jesus who was an early 20th century scholar.  It was Lepin who identified the four competing theologies resulting from Trent’s declarations.   And they are:

Theory I: “The sacrifice does not require a real change in the victim; the Mass contains only a figure of the immolation of Christ.”[v]

Theory II: “The sacrifice requires a real change of the material offered; in the Mass the change takes place in the substance of the bread and wine.”[vi]

Theory III: “The sacrifice requires a real change of the material offered; in the Mass, the change affects Christ himself.” [vii]

Theory IV: “The sacrifice requires a real change; nevertheless, there is in the Mass a change only in the species of the sacrament.”[viii]

Fr. Daly relying on Fr. Lepin’s work describes the various theologians who supported these theories and gives a detailed explanation of their intricacies.  I will leave it to the reader to explore Fr. Daly’s work at length for that level of detail.

At any rate, this all supports our previous findings that the concept of unity did not exist with regard to the doctrine of the Eucharist in the Roman Catholic Church at the time of Trent.  And it also shows that Trent sowed the seeds for greater and not lesser disunity in what followed.

Soli Deo Gloria.

 


[i] [i] Daly, Robert J., S.J.  “Robert Bellarmine and Post-Tridentine Eucharistic Theology”, in From Trent to Vatican II: Historical and Theological Investigations. Ed. Raymond F. Bulman and Frederick J. Parrella. New York: Oxford University Press, 2006.  Pgs. 81-101

[ii] Daly, op. cit. p. 85

[iii] Daly, op. cit. p. 89

[iv] Lepin, Marius.  L’idée du sacrifice de la Messe d’après les théologiens depuis l’origine jusqu’à nos jours (Paris: Beauchesne, 1926) as cited in Daly, op. cit.

[v] Daly, op. cit. p. 89 with explanation on page 90.

[vi] Daly, p. 90

[vii] Daly, p. 91

[viii] Daly, p. 93

Advertisement

Goodreads

Recent Posts

  • A General Theory about the 2020 Election Fraud July 9, 2021
  • Why the Roman Catholic Church MUST canonize Donald Trump June 16, 2018
  • What Everyone Needs to Know about the Paris Climate Accords June 14, 2017
  • Greg Bahnsen – an homage December 11, 2015
  • Pittsburgh, PA Mayor Peduto: Bring us Syrian Muslims! November 11, 2015

Archives

  • July 2021
  • June 2018
  • June 2017
  • December 2015
  • November 2015
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • March 2015
  • September 2014
  • July 2014
  • June 2014
  • May 2014
  • April 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014
  • December 2013
  • October 2013
  • July 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012

Categories

  • Abortion
  • Acts 17
  • America's Christian Heritage
  • Andrew McCarthy
  • Apologetics
  • Armnianism
  • Authority
  • Bryan Cross
  • C2C IP
  • Caste system
  • Catholicism
  • Charles Chaput
  • Christianity
  • Climate Change
  • Darryl Hart
  • David Wood
  • Edgardo Mortara
  • Elections
  • Eucharist
  • Founding Fathers
  • Freedom
  • Garry Wills
  • George Weigel
  • Greg Bahnsen
  • Hermeneutics
  • Islam
  • Jihad
  • Kidnapping
  • Matthew 16
  • Movie Reviews
  • Papacy
  • Paris Climate Accords
  • Pat Buchanan
  • Quran
  • Raymond Brown
  • Reformation
  • Religious Freedom
  • Roger Olson
  • Roman Catholicism
  • SCOTUS
  • Trent
  • U S Constitution
  • Uncategorized
  • Unity
  • William Donohue

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.com

Blogs I Follow

  • anactofmind
  • Roger E. Olson
  • Blogs – The Gospel Coalition
  • The Heidelblog
  • The Jagged Word
  • "In verbo veritatis" (2 Cor 6:7)
  • Old Life
  • John Bugay
  • Glass House
  • Highlands Ministries Online Podcast
  • Return to Rome
  • Mark D. Roberts
  • Called to Communion
  • Larry Hurtado's Blog
  • Societas Christiana (2.0)
  • John Calvin Quotes
  • The Lonely Pilgrim
  • Reformation500
  • Viewpoint
  • Beggars All: Reformation And Apologetics

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

anactofmind

If there is anything in the world that can really be called a man's property, it is surely that which is the result of his mental activity. - Arthur Schopenhauer

Roger E. Olson

If there is anything in the world that can really be called a man's property, it is surely that which is the result of his mental activity. - Arthur Schopenhauer

Blogs – The Gospel Coalition

If there is anything in the world that can really be called a man's property, it is surely that which is the result of his mental activity. - Arthur Schopenhauer

The Heidelblog

Recovering the Reformed Confession

The Jagged Word

Where the sacred & profane collide

"In verbo veritatis" (2 Cor 6:7)

Thoughts and writings of Fr. Joseph A. Komonchak

Old Life

If there is anything in the world that can really be called a man's property, it is surely that which is the result of his mental activity. - Arthur Schopenhauer

John Bugay

God, life, politics, and business

Glass House

My lies will get better

Highlands Ministries Online Podcast

If there is anything in the world that can really be called a man's property, it is surely that which is the result of his mental activity. - Arthur Schopenhauer

Return to Rome

If there is anything in the world that can really be called a man's property, it is surely that which is the result of his mental activity. - Arthur Schopenhauer

Mark D. Roberts

If there is anything in the world that can really be called a man's property, it is surely that which is the result of his mental activity. - Arthur Schopenhauer

Called to Communion

Reformation meets Rome

Larry Hurtado's Blog

Comments on the New Testament and Early Christianity (and related matters)

Societas Christiana (2.0)

If there is anything in the world that can really be called a man's property, it is surely that which is the result of his mental activity. - Arthur Schopenhauer

John Calvin Quotes

The Lonely Pilgrim

A Christian's Road Home to Rome and Journey Onward

Reformation500

Viewpoint

If there is anything in the world that can really be called a man's property, it is surely that which is the result of his mental activity. - Arthur Schopenhauer

Beggars All: Reformation And Apologetics

If there is anything in the world that can really be called a man's property, it is surely that which is the result of his mental activity. - Arthur Schopenhauer

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • anactofmind
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • anactofmind
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar